Monday, January 24, 2022
HomeMiddle ColumnProf. Roger Pielke Jr.: Revisiting the 'Consistent With' Canard -- 'Just don't...

Prof. Roger Pielke Jr.: Revisiting the ‘Consistent With’ Canard — ‘Just don’t use ‘consistent with’ in stretching to link particular extremes with human-caused climate change. It is pure spin’

-

Excerpt: “…it is meaningful to proclaim that the extreme rainfall observed in Colorado several weeks ago are “consistent with” predictions of more intense rainfall associated with human-caused climate change.

Long-time readers will know that I believe the use of the phrase “consistent with” in this context is a canard and devoid of substance. Here is an example using exactly such a construction related to the Colorado floods.

The analogy I’d suggest is a 52-card deck stacked with an extra ace. After being dealt a blackjack (i.e., an ace and a face card) it would indeed be appropriate to proclaim that “such a hand is consistent with expectations for hands dealt from this stacked deck.”  Of course, being deal a 5 and a 2 would also be “consistent with” the stacked deck. For that matter, being dealt a blackjack would also be “consistent with” hands coming from an unstacked deck.
- Advertisment -

Related Articles

John Cook: Climate Deniers Falsely Claim Activists are Anti-Freedom

Quoted in a USA Today call for social media censorship, John Cook, who once thought it amusing to self portrait himself as a NAZI...

What Solution Do Renewable Energy Advocates Offer For The Problem Of Storage?

So I say to these three commenters: it’s time to step up your game. Don’t just make unsupported assertions that wind and solar are...

CBS: Climate Change CAUSED the Tonga Volcanic Eruption

Judge for yourself - on the following video, CBS anchor Nate Burleson appears to claim volcanoes are "happening, and becoming more frequent" because of...