Sunday, August 14, 2022
HomeClimate411The Absurdity of Peer Review

The Absurdity of Peer Review

-

Does it catch fraud or manipulations of data? No, patently not: peer reviewers are not omniscient, so they cannot divine made-up data, nor can they check all the outputs of a lab to see when they’ve simply copy-and-pasted data between papers. If they were, we wouldn’t have the website PubPeer stuffed to the gills with people flagging potentially serious misdemeanors in published papers, nor Retraction Watch’s endless reporting of papers so dodgy they’re expunged from the literature.

- Advertisment -

Related Articles

A Drought in Germany Gets the Media Overexcited

There is a drought in Germany, and naturally the media has gone into hyperdrive to link it to global warming:

All-Electric Forcing in the “Inflation Reduction Act” (up to $14,000 per home)

, this is an incentive that primarily will benefit the already well-to-do; except nearly twice as much as EV’s.”

Southeast Asia at Energy-Climate Crossroad

By Vijay Jayaraj Southeast Asia is at the crossroads of choosing between a climate agenda hostile to fossil fuels and the energy security its...