Monday, August 2, 2021
Home Middle Column The Peer Review Scam: Why not review your own paper?

The Peer Review Scam: Why not review your own paper?

-

The Peer Review Scam: Why not review your own paper?

http://joannenova.com.au/2014/11/the-peer-review-scam-why-not-review-your-own-paper/

If you suffer from an uncontrollable urge to claim that peer review is a part of The Scientific Method (that’s you Matthew Bailes, Pro VC of Swinburne), the bad news just keeps on coming. Now, we can add the terms “Peer Review Rigging” to “Peer-review tampering”, and “Citation Rings”. Not only do personal biases and self-serving interests mean good papers are slowed for years and rejected for inane reasons, but gibberish gets published, and in some fields most results can’t be replicated. Now we find (is anyone surprised?) that some authors are even reviewing their own work. It’s called Peer-Review-Rigging. When the editor asks for suggestions of reviewers, you provide pseudonyms and bogus emails. The editor sends the review to a gmail type address, you pick it up, and voila, you can pretend to be an independent reviewer. One researcher, Hyung-In Moon, was doing this to review his own submissions. He was caught because he sent the reviews back in less than 24 hours. Presumably if he’d waiting a week, no one would have noticed. Nature reports: “THE PEER-REVIEW SCAM” Authors: Cat Ferguson, Adam Marcus and Ivan Oransky are the staff writer and two co-founders, respectively, of Retraction Watch in […]Rating: 8.7/10 (37 votes cast)

— gReader Pro

- Advertisment -

Related Articles

“Greenflation”: What Happens When Climate Activist Politicians Oppose New Mines

The comedic spectacle of activist politicians choking off the supply of raw materials required for their precious green revolution, then wondering at the lack...

Green Deal: Fear of yellow vests rebellion spreads across Europe

Nevertheless, there is concern in Europe’s national capitals that the EU’s ambitious climate policy could cause social unrest. The Italian government, for example, fears...

Clays, Not Water, Are Likely Source of Mars ‘Lakes’

“In planetary science, we often are just inching our way closer to the truth,” Plaut said. “The original paper didn’t prove it was water,...