Sunday, January 29, 2023
HomeMiddle ColumnProf. Roger Pielke Jr.: Revisiting the 'Consistent With' Canard -- 'Just don't...

Prof. Roger Pielke Jr.: Revisiting the ‘Consistent With’ Canard — ‘Just don’t use ‘consistent with’ in stretching to link particular extremes with human-caused climate change. It is pure spin’

-

Excerpt: “…it is meaningful to proclaim that the extreme rainfall observed in Colorado several weeks ago are “consistent with” predictions of more intense rainfall associated with human-caused climate change.

Long-time readers will know that I believe the use of the phrase “consistent with” in this context is a canard and devoid of substance. Here is an example using exactly such a construction related to the Colorado floods.

The analogy I’d suggest is a 52-card deck stacked with an extra ace. After being dealt a blackjack (i.e., an ace and a face card) it would indeed be appropriate to proclaim that “such a hand is consistent with expectations for hands dealt from this stacked deck.”  Of course, being deal a 5 and a 2 would also be “consistent with” the stacked deck. For that matter, being dealt a blackjack would also be “consistent with” hands coming from an unstacked deck.
- Advertisment -

Related Articles

Lomborg Responds to Polar Bear Abundance Challenge

“It does more good for polar bears, and the rest of us, if those trying to help them use accurate facts.” The post Lomborg Responds...

Guardian: Google Are Not Trying Hard Enough to Demonetise Climate Deniers

Essay by Eric Worrall An example greens want demonitised: “Wind Turbines Not Only Shred Birds But Are Piling Up In Landfills“. Google let Daily...

India’s Uncompromising Commitment to Coal

In Asia, the need for sustained economic growth outweighs fanciful visions of a “carbon-free” utopia, making coal the obvious choice for at least several...