Saturday, November 26, 2022
HomeLeft ColumnSlap Down of new study claiming 'Climate change effects increasingly influencing U.S....

Slap Down of new study claiming ‘Climate change effects increasingly influencing U.S. thunderstorm losses’ — ‘Strong public claims simply cannot be supported by the actual research’


Pielke Excerpt: It is here where the reader of the paper might find themself being taken for a fool…’the paper suffers from an obvious fatal error…The paper says nothing conclusive about attribution. It is not an “initial climate change footprint.” It does not support the claim that “climate change effects increasingly influencing US thunderstorm losses.’

In fact, the paper says much the opposite: attribution of losses to climate change was not achieved in the paper.

So let’s recap:

  • Munich Re claimed to have discovered the first “climate change footprint” in economic loss data.
  • That was incorrect.
  • Munich Re claimed in the headline of the press released announcing SEFS13 that “climate change effects increasingly influencing US thunderstorms.”
  • That turns out not to be supported by the paper, which actually concludes the opposite.
  • SEFS13 argues a causal mechanism between increasing humidity, thunderstorm variability and by extension, to normalized losses.
  • The paper fails to report that in the region where most US thunderstorm activity and damage has occurred, the data shows no change in humidity 1973 to 1999 — undercutting its core argument. The paper reports data for an accompanying region where there has been an increase in humidity, but very few losses.

Misleading public claims. An over-hyped press release. A paper which neglects to include materially relevant and contradictory information central to its core argument. All in all, just a normal day in climate science!

- Advertisment -

Related Articles

Antarctica might go green say scientists (only 2km of ice and 50C of warming to go) More great journalism from The Guardian: Climate change is turning Antarctica green, say researchers Or maybe it isn’t. Check out the brave actual prediction:...

MIT climate scientist Dr. Richard Lindzen’s talks in Prague

By Dr. Lubos Motl Richard Lindzen's talk in Prague Richard Lindzen, prof emeritus at MIT, is the most famous atmospheric physicist among the climate skeptics. I...

Study: Earth is becoming GREENER, not BROWNER due to climate change

Guest essay by Dr. Patrick J. Michaels It’s hard to say how many punny posts we came up with using those words when Carol...